South Wales French Car Owners club
Please log in to read the Forum


Varying MPG Returns

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Varying MPG Returns

Post by SCFC_Messiah on Wed 08 Dec 2010, 22:53

Hi guys,

I'm wondering if it's common for the HDi engine to throw up such varying MPG returns between motorway and urban driving?

I travel the country following the Swans, so do a fair bit of motorway miles. I can get roughly 48MPG average over a full tank of diesel on the motorway. This is with a full car - myself and either 3 or 4 passengers, so there's a fair bit of load. I imagine I could increase that figure quite a bit if there was less passengers and I reduced my speed a little - so I'm happy with this return.

However, I also work part time as a delivery driver around Swansea. It's literally all stop-start driving, with the engine being turned on and off on average every 3 miles I'd say - Swansea is kinda known for it's amount of traffic lights (which adds to the stop-starting) and is also very 'hilly'. I'm only getting 30MPG, or 33MPG if I take it easy with the revs. Baring in mind that when I'm working and doing these urban miles, there's only myself in the car - so substantially less weight to haul around.


It's a HDi engine. 110,000 miles. Serviced 1,000 miles ago. Using Millers Diesel Power Sport 4 every couple of tanks. Tyre pressures ok. No other performance issues (no lack of power etc.). Figures are based on the brim-to-brim test, not by needle gauging, so they're fairly accurate.


Would you guys say it's common for the HDi engine to perform so poorly around town? I know the above driving conditions do not lend to good fuel economy (in fact, they're probably as bad as it gets), but I still can't help but feel that 30-33MPG is extremely poor. But then at the same time, as I'm getting decent-ish returns on the motorway, it makes me doubt whether there's a fault after all

Any thoughts or suggestions?

Thanks

SCFC_Messiah
Getting Familier

Town/County : Swansea
Age : 29
Model owned : 3dr 306 HDi in China Blue
Points : 3770
Date Joined : 2009-06-22

Back to top Go down

Re: Varying MPG Returns

Post by MickeyVTS on Thu 09 Dec 2010, 04:49

Sounds ok to me. Average speed on my trip comp when town driving is usually about 18mph.

_____________________________________www.swfco.net____
avatar
MickeyVTS
West Regional Leader

Town/County : Carmarthen
Age : 47
Model owned : '04 Xsara VTS
Dream Car : .
Points : 11966
Date Joined : 2009-03-31

Back to top Go down

Re: Varying MPG Returns

Post by curl666 on Thu 09 Dec 2010, 05:26

Sounds right to me also!

My S1 rallye is getting better MPG than ever in the cold weather, but think this is due to the snow/ice forcing me to drive slower Smile
avatar
curl666
East Member

Town/County : Rhondda Valleys
Age : 29
Model owned : 1.3 106 Rallye & 16v 106 XSi project
Dream Car : one of the above finished :P
Points : 15294
Date Joined : 2008-07-16

http://www.106rallye.co.uk

Back to top Go down

Re: Varying MPG Returns

Post by SCFC_Messiah on Thu 09 Dec 2010, 06:04

I'm glad to hear that. But you hear claims on forums of people saying they only do urban driving an still get 45+MPG and it makes you wonder

My dad owned a Peugeot Expert with a 2.0 HDi engine up until only a few weeks ago and he was only getting 28MPG. And like me, that was all stop-start driving around the city centre. So it was either a case that both of us had faults causing poor MPG, or simply the HDi isn't as efficient around the town as some people say

SCFC_Messiah
Getting Familier

Town/County : Swansea
Age : 29
Model owned : 3dr 306 HDi in China Blue
Points : 3770
Date Joined : 2009-06-22

Back to top Go down

Re: Varying MPG Returns

Post by curl666 on Fri 10 Dec 2010, 04:52

Indeed some of these MPG claims on ebay adverts make me laugh.

avatar
curl666
East Member

Town/County : Rhondda Valleys
Age : 29
Model owned : 1.3 106 Rallye & 16v 106 XSi project
Dream Car : one of the above finished :P
Points : 15294
Date Joined : 2008-07-16

http://www.106rallye.co.uk

Back to top Go down

Re: Varying MPG Returns

Post by _Mike_ on Sat 11 Dec 2010, 06:42

Thats spot on to what a very close friend of mine gets also

I think that the older hdi units just werent so effective at town driving unless you drive like a saint

_____________________________________www.swfco.net____


Team : Sold The RX-8 Evil or Very Mad
Team : 207 GTi THP
avatar
_Mike_
Central Regional Leader

Town/County : Cross Hands
Age : 29
Model owned : 1998 306 GTi6 - VW Polo PD130
Dream Car : Still Deciding
Points : 11603
Date Joined : 2008-07-16

Back to top Go down

Re: Varying MPG Returns

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum